Top Paleo Diet Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

When I first started eating paleo, I made plenty of mistakes that slowed my progress. But I’ve learned from those missteps, and I’m excited to share what I’ve discovered with you.

In this comprehensive guide, I’ll walk you through the most common paleo diet pitfalls and provide practical solutions to help you stay on track.

Whether you’re new to paleo or looking to refine your approach, these tips will help you avoid the mistakes that can derail your health goals.

Understanding the Paleo Philosophy

The paleo diet is based on the idea that we should eat foods similar to what our Paleolithic ancestors consumed. This approach suggests that our bodies are best adapted to these types of foods, potentially leading to improved health and well-being.

A typical paleo diet includes:

• Lean meats
• Fish
• Fruits
• Vegetables
• Nuts
• Seeds

It excludes:

• Grains
• Legumes
• Dairy
• Processed foods
• Refined sugars

While this framework seems straightforward, many people struggle to apply it correctly. Let’s explore some common mistakes and how to avoid them.

The Meat Dilemma: Finding Balance

One of the most frequent errors I see paleo beginners make is overemphasizing meat consumption. It’s easy to assume that paleo means piling your plate high with bacon and steak at every meal.

However, this approach can lead to an imbalanced diet and potential health issues.

The Problem

Excessive meat intake can result in overconsumption of saturated fats and animal protein. This imbalance potentially increases the risk of heart disease and certain cancers. Additionally, focusing too heavily on meat can crowd out other essential nutrients found in fruits, vegetables, and healthy fats.

The Solution

Aim for a balanced plate at each meal. I recommend filling half your plate with non-starchy vegetables, a quarter with lean protein, and the remaining quarter with healthy fats or starchy vegetables.

This approach ensures you’re getting a wide range of nutrients without overdoing it on animal products.

To add variety to your meals, experiment with different protein sources. Try incorporating more fish, eggs, and even some plant-based options like nuts and seeds. This diversity keeps your meals interesting and provides a broader spectrum of nutrients.

For example, you might start your day with a veggie-packed omelet, enjoy a large salad topped with grilled chicken for lunch, and finish with a dinner of baked salmon alongside roasted vegetables and sweet potato.

Remember, the paleo diet emphasizes quality over quantity when it comes to meat. Choose grass-fed, pasture-raised, and wild-caught options when possible.

These sources typically offer better nutrient profiles and are more aligned with the paleo philosophy.

The Carb Conundrum: Embracing Paleo-Friendly Carbs

Another common paleo pitfall is severely restricting carbohydrate intake. While the paleo diet eliminates grains and legumes, it doesn’t mean you should avoid carbs altogether.

In fact, carbohydrates play a crucial role in our overall health and well-being.

The Problem

Extremely low-carb diets can lead to a host of issues, including:

• Fatigue and decreased energy levels
• Reduced athletic performance
• Hormonal imbalances, especially in women
• Difficulty concentrating and mood swings
• Constipation because of lack of fiber

These problems often arise because people mistakenly equate paleo with a ketogenic or very low-carb diet. While some individuals may thrive on lower carb intake, it’s not a requirement of the paleo lifestyle.

The Solution

Incorporate paleo-friendly carbohydrate sources into your diet. Fruits, sweet potatoes, and other starchy vegetables can provide the energy you need without compromising your paleo principles.

These foods offer carbohydrates and essential vitamins, minerals, and fiber.

Some excellent paleo-friendly carb sources include:

• Sweet potatoes and yams
• Butternut squash and pumpkin
• Plantains and bananas
• Apples, berries, and other fruits
• Carrots and beets

I’ve found that carb cycling can be an effective strategy for those looking to optimize their paleo diet for specific fitness goals. This approach involves alternating between higher and lower carb days.

On days with intense workouts, you might increase your carb intake to fuel performance and recovery.

On rest days or days with lighter activity, you might reduce carbs slightly.

For example, on a high-intensity training day, you could start with a breakfast of sweet potato hash with eggs and vegetables, have a post-workout snack of banana with almond butter, enjoy a lunch of grilled chicken with a large serving of roasted butternut squash and greens, and finish with a dinner of grass-fed beef stir-fry with plenty of colorful veggies and a side of plantains.

Remember, the key is to listen to your body and adjust your carb intake based on your person needs, activity level, and health goals.

The Quality Quandary: Not All Paleo Foods Are Created Equal

One mistake I made early in my paleo journey was assuming that anything labeled “paleo” was automatically healthy. This led me to overindulge in paleo-approved treats and processed foods, hindering my progress towards better health.

The Problem

Many paleo-friendly packaged foods and desserts are still high in calories and can impede fat loss or health goals. These products often use concentrated natural sweeteners like honey or maple syrup, which, while paleo-approved, can still spike blood sugar and contribute to excess calorie intake if consumed in large quantities.

Additionally, some paleo-labeled products may contain ingredients that, while technically allowed, aren’t optimal for health when consumed regularly. For example, almond flour is a common ingredient in paleo baked goods, but it’s very calorie-dense and can be inflammatory for some people when consumed in large amounts.

The Solution

Focus on whole, unprocessed foods as the foundation of your diet. These should make up the majority of your meals.

Treat paleo-approved desserts and snacks as occasional indulgences as opposed to dietary staples.

When shopping for paleo-friendly products, always read the ingredient list carefully. Look for items with minimal ingredients, all of which you can pronounce and recognize.

Be wary of products that contain a long list of “natural” additives or preservatives.

I’ve found that learning to make your own paleo treats using whole food ingredients can be a game-changer. This way, you have control over what goes into them and can adjust the sweetness to your liking.

For example, you might experiment with making energy balls using dates, nuts, and cocoa powder, or try baking with green plantains instead of nut flours.

Here’s a simple recipe for paleo energy balls that I love:

1. Blend 1 cup of pitted dates with 1 cup of raw almonds in a food processor.
2. Add 2 tablespoons of cocoa powder and a pinch of sea salt.
3. Process until the mixture starts to stick together.
4. Roll into small balls and refrigerate.

These make for a great occasional treat or pre-workout snack, and you know exactly what’s in them.

Remember, the paleo diet emphasizes nutrient-dense, whole foods. While it’s okay to enjoy paleo-friendly treats now and then, they shouldn’t form the basis of your diet.

The Nutrient Navigation: Avoiding Deficiencies

Eliminating entire food groups can potentially lead to nutrient deficiencies if you’re not careful. This is a mistake I see many paleo dieters make, especially in the long term.

It’s crucial to ensure you’re getting all the necessary nutrients while following a paleo lifestyle.

The Problem

Without proper planning, paleo dieters may become deficient in certain nutrients, including:

• Calcium: Often obtained from dairy products in standard diets
• Vitamin D: Also commonly found in fortified dairy products
• B vitamins: Particularly B12, which is mainly found in animal products
• Iodine: Often added to table salt, which many paleo dieters avoid
• Magnesium: Found in high quantities in whole grains and legumes

These deficiencies can lead to various health issues, from weakened bones to fatigue and cognitive problems.

The Solution

Diversify your diet and focus on nutrient-dense foods. Here are some strategies I’ve found effective:

1. Calcium: Incorporate leafy greens like kale, collard greens, and bok choy into your meals.

Sardines and canned salmon with bones are excellent sources of calcium.

Bone broth is another great option.

2. Vitamin D: Spend time outdoors to get sun exposure, which helps your body produce vitamin D.

Include fatty fish like salmon, mackerel, and sardines in your diet.

Consider supplementation if you live in a low-sunlight area or have limited sun exposure.

3. B vitamins: Organ meats like liver are incredibly rich in B vitamins.

If you’re not a fan of organ meats, ensure you’re eating a variety of other meats, fish, and eggs.

Nutritional yeast is a great B-vitamin source for those who eat less animal products.

4. Iodine: Sea vegetables like nori, kelp, and dulse are rich in iodine.

Fish and seafood are also good sources.

5. Magnesium: Include plenty of nuts, especially almonds and cashews, in your diet.

Leafy greens and avocados are also good sources.

Here’s an example of a nutrient-dense paleo meal:

• Grilled salmon (rich in vitamin D, B vitamins, and iodine)
• Sautéed kale and chard (high in calcium and magnesium)
• Roasted sweet potato (good source of complex carbs and vitamins)
• Avocado slices (provides healthy fats and magnesium)
• Sprinkle of pumpkin seeds (zinc and magnesium)

I highly recommend working with a nutritionist familiar with the paleo diet to ensure you’re meeting all your nutritional needs. They can help you create a personalized plan and determine if any supplementation is necessary.

Remember, the goal of the paleo diet is to optimize health, not to create new health problems through nutrient deficiencies. By being mindful of potential shortfalls and actively working to address them, you can enjoy all the benefits of a paleo lifestyle without compromising your nutritional status.

The Sustainability Struggle: Making Paleo Work Long-Term

One of the biggest challenges with the paleo diet is maintaining it over time. Many people find the restrictions too difficult to sustain, leading to yo-yo dieting and frustration.

However, with the right approach, the paleo lifestyle can be both enjoyable and sustainable.

The Problem

Strict adherence to paleo principles can lead to several issues:

• Burnout from constantly planning and preparing meals
• Social isolation because of difficulty eating out or at social gatherings
• Feelings of deprivation, leading to binge eating or completely abandoning the diet
• Stress from trying to be “perfect” all the time

These challenges can make it hard to stick with the paleo diet long-term, even if you’re seeing positive results.

The Solution

Adopt a more flexible approach to paleo eating. Here are some strategies I’ve found helpful:

1. Follow the 80/20 rule: Stick to paleo principles 80% of the time and allow for some non-paleo foods in moderation for the remaining 20%.

This flexibility can make the diet more sustainable and enjoyable.

2. Plan ahead for social situations: If you know you’ll be dining out, research paleo-friendly options at the restaurant beforehand.

Many restaurants are happy to accommodate dietary restrictions if you ask.

3. Prepare paleo-friendly versions of your favorite foods: Missing pizza?

Try a cauliflower crust version.

Craving pasta? Experiment with zucchini noodles or spaghetti squash.

4. Batch cook and meal prep: Spend a few hours on the weekend preparing meals for the week.

This can save time and reduce stress during busy weekdays.

5. Focus on addition, not subtraction: Instead of dwelling on foods you can’t eat, explore new paleo-friendly ingredients and recipes.

This mindset shift can make the diet feel more abundant and less restrictive.

6. Be kind to yourself: If you eat a non-paleo food, don’t beat yourself up.

Simply return to your paleo habits at the next meal.

Here’s an example of how I might approach a week of flexible paleo eating:

• Monday to Friday: Stick to strict paleo meals
• Saturday: Enjoy a non-paleo dinner out with friends
• Sunday: Have a paleo brunch, then a family dinner that might include some non-paleo sides

Remember, the goal is long-term health and well-being, not perfection. By allowing some flexibility, you’re more likely to stick with the paleo lifestyle in the long run.

The Mindset Mistake: Focusing on Restriction Instead of Abundance

A common psychological pitfall in the paleo diet is viewing it as a set of restrictions as opposed to an opportunity to explore new, nourishing foods. This negative mindset can make the diet feel like a punishment as opposed to a path to better health.

The Problem

A restrictive mindset can lead to several issues:

• Feelings of deprivation and resentment towards the diet
• Increased likelihood of binge eating or giving up on the diet altogether
• Missing out on the joy of exploring new foods and flavors
• Stress and anxiety around food choices

When you’re constantly thinking about what you can’t eat, it’s easy to lose sight of the positive aspects of the paleo lifestyle.

The Solution

Shift your focus to all the delicious, whole foods you can eat on the paleo diet. Here are some strategies to help change your mindset:

1. Experiment with new recipes: Challenge yourself to try one new paleo recipe each week.

This can help you find out about new favorite foods and keep your meals exciting.

2. Explore different cuisines: Many traditional cuisines from around the world naturally align with paleo principles.

Thai, Greek, and Mexican dishes, for example, can often be easily adapted to fit paleo guidelines.

3. Focus on food quality: Instead of thinking about restrictions, focus on choosing the highest quality ingredients you can afford.

Savor the flavor of fresh, local produce and well-sourced meats.

4. Celebrate what your body can do: Pay attention to how eating paleo makes you feel.

Do you have more energy?

Better digestion? Improved sleep?

Focusing on these positive changes can help motivate you to continue.

5. Create a list of paleo foods you love: Whenever you feel restricted, refer to this list to remind yourself of all the delicious options available to you.

Here’s an exercise I found helpful: Create a list of 10 new paleo-friendly foods you’d like to try. Commit to incorporating one new food into your diet each week.

This could be a new vegetable, a type of fish you’ve never tried, or an exotic fruit.

For example, your list might include:

1. Jicama
2. Sardines
3. Dragon fruit
4. Kohlrabi
5. Beef heart
6. Plantains
7. Kelp noodles
8. Quail eggs
9. Rutabaga
10. Jackfruit

By focusing on exploration and abundance, you can improve your paleo experience from one of restriction to one of culinary adventure and personal growth.

The Adaptation Adventure: Giving Your Body Time to Adjust

Many people give up on the paleo diet too soon because they experience initial discomfort or don’t see immediate results. However, it’s important to understand that your body needs time to adapt to this new way of eating.

The Problem

The transition to a paleo diet can cause temporary side effects such as:

• Fatigue
• Headaches
• Digestive issues like constipation or diarrhea
• Cravings for non-paleo foods
• Irritability or mood swings

These symptoms, often referred to as the “paleo flu,” can be discouraging and may lead people to abandon the diet prematurely.

The Solution

Understanding that these symptoms are often part of the adaptation process can help you push through the initial discomfort. Here are some strategies to make the transition smoother:

1. Gradual transition: Instead of going “cold turkey,” try eliminating one food group at a time.

For example, you might start by cutting out grains, then a week later eliminate legumes, and so on.

2. Stay hydrated: Drink plenty of water to help your body adjust and reduce symptoms like headaches and fatigue.
3. Increase your salt intake: As you reduce processed foods, you may need to add more salt to your meals to maintain electrolyte balance.
4. Eat enough carbs: Don’t cut carbs too drastically at first.

Include plenty of paleo-friendly carbs like sweet potatoes and fruit to help with energy levels.

5. Prioritize sleep: Aim for 7-9 hours of quality sleep each night to support your body’s adaptation process.
6. Be patient: Give your body time to adjust, typically 2-4 weeks.

Keep a journal to track your progress and any improvements in how you feel.

Here’s an example of how you might structure a gradual transition to paleo:

• Week 1: Eliminate grains and sugar
• Week 2: Cut out legumes
• Week 3: Remove dairy
• Week 4: Focus on increasing vegetable intake and improving meat quality

Remember, everyone’s body is different, and the adaptation period can vary. Some people feel great within a few days, while others may take a month or more to fully adjust.

Be patient with yourself and listen to your body throughout the process.

The Individuality Insight: Personalizing Your Paleo Approach

Perhaps the most significant mistake is assuming that one-size-fits-all when it comes to the paleo diet. What works for one person may not work for another, and it’s crucial to tailor the diet to your person needs and preferences.

The Problem

Following a strict paleo template without considering your person needs can lead to several issues:

• Suboptimal results in terms of health and well-being
• Difficulty sticking to the diet long-term
• Potential nutrient deficiencies or imbalances
• Ignoring personal food intolerances or sensitivities

The Solution

Pay close attention to how your body responds to different foods and adjust your paleo approach accordingly. Here are some strategies to help personalize your paleo diet:

1. Keep a food journal: For at least two weeks, record everything you eat and how it makes you feel.

Look for patterns in energy levels, digestion, mood, and any other symptoms.

2. Experiment with macronutrient ratios: Some people thrive on a higher carb version of paleo, while others do better with more fats.

Try adjusting your intake of carbs, proteins, and fats to find what works best for you.

3. Consider your activity level: If you’re very active or an athlete, you may need more carbs than someone who’s sedentary.
4. Listen to your body: If certain paleo-approved foods don’t agree with you, don’t force yourself to eat them just because they’re “allowed.”
5. Work with a professional: Consider consulting with a nutritionist or functional medicine practitioner who can help you tailor the paleo diet to your specific health needs and goals.
6. Be flexible: Your needs may change over time because of factors like age, stress levels, or health conditions.

Be willing to adjust your approach as needed.

Here’s an exercise to help you start personalizing your paleo approach:

1. List your top 3 health goals (e.g., fat loss, better digestion, more energy)
2. Identify 5 paleo-friendly foods that make you feel great
3. Note any paleo-approved foods that don’t agree with you
4. Consider your lifestyle factors (work schedule, exercise routine, stress levels)
5. Based on this information, create a personalized paleo meal plan for a week

Remember, the paleo diet is a framework, not a rigid set of rules. By tailoring it to your person needs and preferences, you’re more likely to see positive results and stick with it long-term.

Key Takeaways

1. Balance your plate with plenty of vegetables, not just meat
2. Don’t fear paleo-friendly carbs like fruits and starchy vegetables
3. Focus on food quality, not just paleo labels
4. Be mindful of potential nutrient deficiencies and diversify your diet
5. Adopt a flexible approach for long-term sustainability
6. Shift your mindset from restriction to abundance
7. Give your body time to adapt to the new way of eating
8. Personalize your paleo approach based on your person needs and responses

People Also Asked

What foods are allowed on the paleo diet?

The paleo diet typically includes lean meats, fish, fruits, vegetables, nuts, and seeds. It excludes grains, legumes, dairy, processed foods, and refined sugars.

How long does it take to see results on the paleo diet?

Results can vary, but many people report feeling better within a few weeks. Significant changes in weight or health markers may take several months.

Is the paleo diet good for fat loss?

Many people experience fat loss on the paleo diet because of the elimination of processed foods and focus on whole, nutrient-dense options. However, person results may vary.

Can you eat potatoes on the paleo diet?

White potatoes are generally avoided on strict paleo diets, but sweet potatoes and other starchy vegetables are often included.

Is the paleo diet safe for everyone?

While many people benefit from the paleo diet, it’s always best to ask with a healthcare professional before making significant dietary changes, especially if you have existing health conditions.

How do I get enough calcium on the paleo diet?

Good paleo sources of calcium include leafy greens, sardines with bones, and bone broth. Some people may need to consider supplementation.

Can I drink alcohol on the paleo diet?

Strict paleo diets exclude alcohol, but some people choose to include small amounts of paleo-friendly options like dry wine or clear spirits occasionally.

Is the paleo diet anti-inflammatory?

Many people find the paleo diet helps reduce inflammation because of it’s focus on whole foods and elimination of processed items. However, person responses may vary.

How do I handle eating out on the paleo diet?

When eating out, focus on simple meat and vegetable dishes, ask for substitutions when possible, and don’t be afraid to explain your dietary needs to the server.

Can the paleo diet help with autoimmune conditions?

Some people with autoimmune conditions report improvements on the paleo diet, particularly versions like the Autoimmune Protocol (AIP). However, it’s crucial to work with a healthcare provider for managing any medical condition.

Click to Learn more about Paleo Diets Mistakes to Avoid